Cruising stocks floated about as well as a sack of bricks on Wednesday. A Morgan Stanley analyst made negative comments about the industry, and questioned one company’s ability to withstand a recession.
Analyst Jamie Rollo lowered his price target for Carnival Cruise Lines (CCL) to $7, and placed a worst-case scenario price target of $0 on the stock. Carnival, the world’s largest cruise line, dropped 14% on the news to close at $8.87.
Competitor Royal Caribbean Cruises (RCL) fell 9.57% to close at $36.02, and Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings (NCLH) lost 9.4% to close at $11.57. All three stocks are near their respective 52-week lows.
Rollo raised legitimate concerns about Carnival’s ability to raise capital if an economic downturn should occur. The company lost $1.8 billion in its most recent quarter.
According to the chart, Rollo’s base-case price target of $7 is likely to be met. Carnival is trapped in a bearish channel (diagonal lines). The channel predicts that Carnival will fall below $6, which is the mean of the channel.
Chart Source: TradeStation
Carnival’s volume has been steadily increasing over the past three weeks (shaded yellow). The increase in turnover could be a sign of institutional selling. Wednesday’s selloff occurred on 2.5x Carnival’s normal volume.
According to Carnival’s RSI (relative strength index), this stock isn’t yet oversold. Even if it was, I wouldn’t buy Carnival at its current price.
Carnival has been oversold on five occasions since December (arrows). While each oversold reading led to a bounce, the stock eventually reached a lower low on every occasion.
The chart of Royal Caribbean Cruises is nearly identical to that of Carnival. RCL’s chart has a similar bear channel, a comparable increase in volume, and five oversold RSI bounces, just like Carnival.
Chart Source: TradeStation
The chart of Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings also has a similar look.
Chart Source: TradeStation
Here’s the takeaway: All three of these stocks are going lower. The downside momentum is strong in this sector, and nearby support — formed just last week — is unlikely to prevent a move to fresh 52-week lows for all three names.
However, these stocks are priced for an industry-wide calamity, and I’m not sure that’s realistic.
Rollo’s worst-case scenario is based on a potential economic downturn, but cruising enthusiasts tend to be older and wealthier. They are among the least susceptible to a recession.
Bottom line: These stocks should continue to sink, but not all the way to Davy Jones’ Locker. If I can get Carnival at the low end of the channel — under $5 — I’ll dive in.
